Sunday, January 31, 2016

Atomic Bomb

The mushroom cloud above Nagasaki, Japan from the atomic bomb
The Atomic Bomb
At the start of World War II in 1939 the atomic bomb had not yet been invented. However, scientists discovered about that time that a powerful explosion might be possible by splitting an atom. This type of bomb could destroy large cities in a single blast and would change warfare forever.


Albert Einstein
Albert Einstein came up with many of the theories that helped scientists in making the atomic bomb. When he realized that such a bomb could be made, he was frightened about what might happen if Hitler and Germany learned how to make the bomb first. He wrote a letter to US President Franklin Roosevelt telling him about the atom bomb. As a result, Roosevelt set up the Manhattan Project.

Manhattan Project
The Manhattan Project was the name for the research and development program for the atomic bomb. It started small, but as the bomb became more real, the United States added scientists and funding to be sure they were the first to have the bomb. Ironically, many of the scientists involved in making the bomb had defected from Germany. By the end of the project, funding had reached $2 billion and there were around 200,000 people working on the project.

The First Atomic Bomb
On July 16, 1945 the first atomic bomb was exploded in the New Mexico desert. The explosion was massive and the equivalent to 18,000 tons of TNT. Scientists figured that the temperature at the center of the explosion was three times hotter than at the center of the sun.

Although the scientists were happy they had successfully made the bomb, they also were sad and fearful. This bomb would change the world and could cause mass destruction and death. When President Harry Truman heard of the bomb's success he wrote "We have discovered the most terrible bomb in the history of the world".

Deciding to Drop the Bomb
By the time the first atomic bomb had been made, Germany had already surrendered and World War II in Europe was over. Japan was defeated as well, but would not surrender. The US was contemplating an invasion of Japan. Army leaders figured that anywhere from 500,000 to 1 million US and Allied soldiers would die in an invasion. President Truman decided to drop the atomic bomb instead.


Hiroshima
On August 6, 1945 an atomic bomb named Little Boy was dropped on Hiroshima, Japan. The explosion was huge, the city was destroyed, and tens of thousands of people were killed. The bomb was dropped by a plane named the Enola Gay which was piloted by Colonel Paul Tibbetts. The bomb itself was over 10 feet long and weighed around 10,000 pounds. A small parachute was on the bomb in order to slow its drop and allow the plane time to fly away from the blast zone.


Fat Man

Nagasaki
Despite witnessing the terrible destruction of the bomb on Hiroshima, Emperor Hirohito and Japan still refused to surrender. Three days later, on August 9, 1945, another atomic bomb, nicknamed Fat Man, was dropped on Nagasaki, Japan. Again the devastation was horrible.

Surrender

Six days after the bombing of Nagasaki, Emperor Hirohito and Japan surrendered to US forces. The Emperor announced this on the radio. It was the first time most Japanese had heard his voice.

Interesting Facts
The lead scientist on the Manhattan Project was J. Robert Oppenheimer. He is often called the "father of the atomic bomb".
The first bomb dropped on Hiroshima was made from uranium. Hiroshima was chosen because it was a large port city with an army base. 
The second bomb dropped on Nagasaki was made from plutonium, which was even more powerful than uranium.
It is thought that at least 135,000 people died from the Hiroshima explosion and another 70,000 in Nagasaki. Many of these people were civilians including women and children.





Watch this 4 minute video and hear first-hand accounts from the air and ground, re-telling every memory from the day the world first witnessed the horrors of atomic warfare. 

Watch this video showing the final briefing where American troops are told this will just be another day, another bombing. Soon enough, however, the event causes a media storm. Hear first hand accounts from the crew that flew the atom bomb to Japan.

Pay close attention to this video as we learn how about how Harry Trumen came to the decision to order the destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. 

Comment on the blog: 
Discuss one of the three reasons that Truman decided to drop the bomb and tell us if you agree or disagree with his reasoning. 

27 comments:

  1. From what i understand he wanted it to be a surprise... but i also think that their is no good reason to bomb the japanese..............................

    ReplyDelete
  2. From what i understand he wanted it to be a surprise... but i also think that their is no good reason to bomb the japanese..............................

    ReplyDelete
  3. One of Truman's reasons was the estimated cost of human life from an invasion. American casualties would have been from 500,000 to 1 million deaths from an invasion, not including the Japanese people who would die anyway. The bomb was more efficient because it was done quickly and saved soldiers the guilt of killing the poor Japanese people themselves. I agree with Truman's reasoning. It was forced upon him. If he would have said no to the bomb, I think it would have been costly and downright stupid. Sadly, he did make the decision to obliterate hundreds of thousands of Japanese lives. He must have had tremendous guilt and regret for the rest of his life, even if it was the right decision. Ready for a weird analogy? It's like a wrestler getting pounded. If the Japanese would have tapped out, we would have left them alone. But they were adamant on their position, so we had to personally deliver a KO. Being the nice country we are, we didn't deliver our two remaining atomic bombs, Thin Man and The Gadget.

    Overall, I don't think it was a dark day in U.S. history. But it definitely was for Japan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jacob it probably cost the Japanese pretty close the same amount of deaths for them.

      Delete
    2. True it cost them the same but it saved hundreds of thousands of Americans.

      Delete
    3. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  4. I understand why Truman decided to drop the Atomic bomb but it was a very hard decision to make in order to end the war and end thousands of japanese lives. Its very sad I would not have been able to kill that many lives. :(

    ReplyDelete
  5. One reason he decided to drop the bomb that stood out to me was the fact that it would save so many American lives. Just think, if we would have went to war, or done essentially anything different from the bomb, so many of our troop members would have probably perished. This was a huge decision for Truman to make. But in America we do have strong points of unity and patriotism in some places. It was selfless for him to make this decision in the way that he was saving his country. Althoigh, It was selfish in the way that it can be viewed as an easy way out. Japan was nearly defenseless. You can't fight back a bomb while it's happening! It was out of the blue and tragic, yes, but when you are leading your country it is your job to protect it. I'm not saying I believe Japan was planning on coming to our country and killing thousands of us, or that I agree with taking ones life, but any other route other than the bomb would have cost our American lives. When it comes down to the president getting to choose, I see why he picked what he did.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good thoughts. The only thing is (I don't know what context you were using this in) that Japan wasn't going to come to our country and kill thousands of us. We were going into their house to take them out. They weren't strong enough to come into America and beat us up on our home turf. Especially with four a-bombs in waiting.
      If it didn't come across the right way, I'm just agreeing with you :).

      Delete
  6. What I got from the video was he did not have much of a choice but one of the reasons Truman was dropped the bomb for was because he did not want anymore Americans dying and so much money was put into it that he felt like he had to.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Even though Truman had no choose but to use the bomb, I wish that negotiated better alternatives instead of killing millions. But I can see why he did it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. One of the reasons he decided to drop the bomb was because he wanted to save American lives and shorten the war. I don't know if i agree or disagree because in the video it said that he had an option to drop the bomb over a deserted area to show the Japanese America's power and i feel like that would have been smarter, considering that we had more than one bomb ready. But if Japan still would not have given up than it might have been stupid, but at least the Japanese would know what America was capable of.. In the first video it made me so sad to see all the kids and innocent people before the bomb hit because its not like they deserved to die or were the ones fighting us and that would be like if we were just at our house having a family dinner or at school talking to our friends and then the next instant we were all just killed. I think the bomb did a lot more damage and caused a lot more deaths than estimated and was honestly just awful but i understand why he decided to do use it, i just don't fully agree with his decision.

    ReplyDelete
  9. One of Truman's reasons to drop the bomb was that they had already spent so much money on it that it would be a waste not to use it. I disagree, and don't think that is a justifiable cause to drop a bomb on many innocent people. I'm not saying I'm against the bombing...I believe it was probably the only effective solution, considering the Emperor was so recluctant to give up.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right, its so upsetting to think about all of the innocent people that died from it, but it is not like there was a better solution with the options that were given at the time :(

      Delete
  10. I am feeling totally shocked right now. I knew about the bomb and how terrible it was, but I don’t think I knew exactly how terrible it was. This comment could be long, sorry. :) The decision to drop the bomb makes no sense at all! I understand that he wanted a quick and efficient way to end the war, but I don’t think that was the smartest way of doing it.The scientists said that this was the most deadly bomb in the world and that it’s a terrible weapon. So why the heck would you use it on a country!?! Sure, they had tested it before to make sure it worked, but they didn’t know how many lives it would take. Maybe they didn’t even know that the radiation from the bomb would kill thousands more years after the attack! It just makes no sense to me. “Oh hey, we have this bomb that everyone agrees is the most terrible weapon ever and it would be really bad if the Germans or Japanese got it because they would use it to kill thousands of people. So since we’re so much nicer than the,m, it’s use it on Japan!” great idea, guys. I understand why it was an option, but I really feel like we could have done something else! It would even be better if we had just used some smaller bombs. Now, I don’t have all the details, and I don’t know what it was like to be there in the time, but I still feel like nothing justifies killing thousands of innocent people. It shocked me when Truman said to his wife that “We’ll end the war a year sooner, and think of all the kids that won’t be killed.” What he really meant was think of all the American kids who won’t be killed. But think of all the Japanese kids that will be killed! Sure, Japan did some bad stuff, but so did we! Everyone has done bad stuff in their life! Does that mean we should drop an atom bomb on everyone? As you can probably tell, I am completely against Truman’s decision to drop the bomb. Like I said before, I don’t think anything justifies killing so many innocent people. I don’t blame Truman for the bomb though. He was under a lot of pressure from this decision and from being the new president. And the poor guy had to step into FDR”s shoes. How hard could that be! I don’t like that we dropped the bombs, but I can’t change the fact that we did, so I’ll just hope no one attacks anybody else and we don’t start WWIII

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the only way to justify an evil is by preventing a greater evil. I get what you're saying. You're saying we stooped to their level rather than staying classy and doing it the 'man' way. Japan wasn't thinking of us when they killed 2400+ people at Pearl Harbor. This is war. Sometimes in war feelings need to be put aside so that things get done. In the Cold War, atomic bombs were not used and the war went on for 45 long years. How much longer would World War II have lasted without the use of a-bombs? Maybe we did stoop low, but those kids would have died anyway from a necessary invasion. The body count (from both sides!) would have been astronomically higher without the use of an atomic bomb. Everyone wanted this brutal war to just be over. Japan's pride brought this on themselves.

      Delete
    2. I don’t think I agree with you. I don’t think you should ever put feeling to the side. Yes, It may have been necessary to do that, but why couldn’t we have tried something else first? Even killing less people would have been better. Yes, Japan’s pride and refusal to surrender did force us to have to do something about it, but I don’t believe we should have gone as far as we did so soon. I’m not sure what other tactics we tried before we dropped the bombs, if we tried any others at all, but I know if it had been me as the president, I would have done everything possible to avoid bombing Japan. I looked up the death count, and it said that 129,000–246,000+ people were killed. And that was just the initial attack! I do understand what you’re saying about how long it would have taken, though. I guess that’s just a choice of deciding when you just let the war go on and when you bomb everyone. It was a terribly brutal war, and I understand Truman’s decision to do it, even if it is tragic.

      Delete
    3. Our first option was reasoning with Japan. Hirohito wasn't having any of it. So we first bombed Tokyo with our B-29s, killing 225,000 people combined in two air raids. That was with airplanes. Normal bombing. Why did the Emperor not see it then? Japan was obviously losing, but they were determined to continue fighting. There was no option to kill less people. Yes, up to 246,000+ people may have been killed. But if we would have been classy and done close-hand fighting, Americans would have lost near a million and Japanese would have lost 5-10 million soldiers and civilians.
      P.S. that stat is from Forbes so maybe don't quote me on that.


      http://www.forbes.com/sites/henrymiller/2012/08/01/the-nuking-of-japan-was-a-tactical-and-moral-imperative/#668a28bd4881

      Delete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. One of the reasons that Truman decided to drop the A-bomb was because of the momentum the Manhattan project had, why build a bomb, costing the US a lot of money, and then in the end, not use it? The bomb was built to be dropped on the enemy, and I believe that once you've thought it all out, that in the end it was the right thing to do. It did take many Japanese civilian lives, but considering that the Japanese fight to the death and never surrender, just as many lives might have been taken anyway, but that includes American lives. When the Emperor of Japan didn't surrender after the first bomb, I think that shows how "to the death" they want to fight. It was a terrible thing we had to, but under the circumstances, it was the only option that could both save lives of American soldiers, and end the war.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think one of the reasons Harry Truman decided to drop the Atomic Bomb is so he could save American lives. I do not agree with the decision of him dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima because it took and estimated 140,000 Japanese lives. The effect of the A-Bomb was drastic. How could somebody take so many countless lives’? It is true; he was under a lot of pressure of making that decision. In the end, I think it was pretty hard for him to change his mind after he put all that money and time into the invention of the bomb.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I get what you are saying martin but it was either that or have the same amount of people die (or more) from Japan plus a couple hundred thousand Americans die as well.

      Delete
  14. one reason Truman dropped the bomb was because Japan wouldn't surrender so they had to invade to make them surrender but that would mean many American soldiers dying. Truman didn't want more people dying than was necessary. dropping the bomb killed less people than have an invasion(s). there's no telling how many invasions could have happened, we could have had hundreds or just one. Truman just cut his losses and bombed Japan. I think it was the right decision because there is no telling how many invasions there could have been but the bomb we would just have to drop a couple and the war is over.

    ReplyDelete
  15. One of the reasons was saving the amount of American lives. I feel bad for Truman because he was stuck in such difficult decision. I see how not dropping the bomb would be bad too because, if we did not then they might have overpowered again and won. But, dropping the bomb is also very bad. Killing innocent Japanese civilians in order to win a war is something no one would ever want to decide on. I respect his choice and I feel I would have done the same.

    ReplyDelete