Few Japanese lived on the North American continent before the late 1800’s. Then, as Japanese industry grew, it drove farmers from their land. Many of the homeless moved to America looking for new chances to succeed. American businessmen were looking for cheap labor to build the railroads and work long hours in the fields. The Chinese had been doing this, but in 1882, the Chinese Exclusion Act stopped them from moving to America. The Japanese quickly took their place. In 1890 the census counted 2,039 Japanese in the U.S. Twenty years later there were more than 72,000, including 40,000 in farming, 10,000 railroad workers, and 4,000 cannery workers.
The first group of Japanese moving to America were young men, ready to work. Most of these men planned to get rich then go back to Japan. But this changed in the early 1900’s, when many settled down and started families. Many Japanese Americans rented or leased property and were incredibly successful at growing large amounts of fruits and vegetables on small pieces of land. They used Japanese businesses that began to bunch up in areas of west coast cities. Japanese Americans rarely had to look outside of their own ethnic group for anything, including marriage.
At least part of the reason that Japanese kept to themselves was a result of prejudice. As the Empire of Japan gained power in the Pacific, Japanese Americans gained success and power in their new country, and many whites disliked them. The tradition of discriminating against Asians that began with the Chinese continued with the Japanese, as state and national governments passed laws limiting their rights. These laws banned Japanese immigrants, or Issei, from owning or renting land. It was almost impossible for Japanese Americans to get skilled jobs in businesses outside their community. The Issei were forbidden from citizenship themselves, so they focused their hopes on their children. This first generation of Japanese born in America, or Nisei, appreciated both their cultural background and their adopted country. Both generations focused on hard work and education as the keys to success. But often even that wasn’t enough, and many educated Nisei could not find jobs in the areas in which they studied. Still, the Nisei continued to accept many of the American ways while mixing them with their ethnic traditions and identities.
The attack on Pearl Harbor scared many Americans. They suddenly came to see the Japanese Americans living in their country as a threat to national safety. A day after the attack, President Franklin D. Roosevelt asked Congress to declare war on Japan. The request was approved, with
only one representative voting against it. On the west coast particularly, many citizens believed the Issei and Nissei were loyal to Japan. Large numbers of Japanese Americans on the coast combined with traditional prejudices led to cries for action. People worried that a Japanese attack could strike again at any time. President Roosevelt suddenly had a decision to make about what to do with the thousands of Japanese Americans living in the United States.
President Roosevelt gave in to political and public pressure and signed a bill. Executive Order 9066 gave the War Department the power to create military exclusion areas, or places where Japanese would not be allowed to live. By 1943, more than 110,000 Japanese Americans had been forced from their homes and moved to camps in far-off inland areas of the United States.
Today, the decision to intern Japanese Americans is usually seen by historians and legal scholars as a serious mistake. In fact, no Japanese were convicted of spying or sabotage. In 1988, the US congress passed laws which officially apologized for the internment on behalf of the U.S. government. The legislation said that government actions were based on "race prejudice, war hysteria, and a failure of political leadership". The U.S. government eventually gave more than $1.6 billion to pay back Japanese Americans who had been interned or their surviving family members.
Comment on the blog: What are your thoughts on the Japanese being relocated during this time?
I think it was unwelcoming for Japanese people wanting to emigrate to the states. Hearing that Japanese-Americans are fighting the war shouldn't they have more respect?
ReplyDeleteI thought that it was really rude and disrespectful to the Japaneese living in America and the ones fighting for their country. Many had been there a very long time and they treated them as if they had just arrived and had no life in America. I think that they made a huge mistake by doing that. They basically found a threat and did not trust their own citizens just because of their ethnicity. It was also sad that in the video it said that most of the Japanese returning home, proud and with their heads held high, returned to find everything they owned in ruins.
ReplyDeleteMy thoughts on the Japanese being relocated during WWII is terrible they are american now and they might be from Japan or be the kids of Japanese but that does not change that they are american.
ReplyDeleteMy thoughts about the Japenese being relocated during this time are very similar to the previous comments. I thought it was very uncalled for, disgraceful, and rude. And there wasn't any sympathy shown. Our country has definitely had its moment of discrimination
ReplyDeletei agree with tannah, i definitely think our country has been very rude at times
DeleteI wouldn't call it discrimination, it's more like that our country had to make this decision in order to eliminate at least most of the chances of Japanese Americans defecting, I'm not saying the did or would have if they weren't sent to the camps, but it was more of an extreme cautious maneuver than an act of real discrimination.
DeleteOh, and as you can see in my second post, It definitely wasn't discrimination because those who went to internment camps were, well, definitely disloyal because they didn't state the Pledge of Allegiance to the American Flag, that's why they were sent there. (see more in my comments)
DeleteIts like what we talked about today, we have assumptions of what the Japanese are like and we judge them because of that. I understand that it was for security reasons but the camps look like concentration camps too me.
ReplyDeletei think its not right that the people move them to the camps like that but, also i think some appreciate it because if they were out on their own they would probably have no money to survive...
ReplyDeleteMy thoughts on the Japanese being relocated are as follows: How could anybody be so cruel to somebody they don't even know? As Jonathan said; it is like what we talked about yesterday. When you assume who somebody is and you don't take the time to get to know that person. If people would have gotten to get to know some of the Japanese, they might see that they're really just like us! We can't assume who somebody is on the outside until we really get to know them on the inside.
ReplyDeleteI can understand why the government thought they needed to contain the Japanese, but it was still a cruel thing to do. Obviously these Japanese people don't want to live in Japan for whatever reason, be it persecution, hunger, war, etc. It just seems silly to think that they might go back to being loyal to Japan so we need to get rid of them. This country as a whole judged them before we really knew them.
ReplyDeleteI think if we would have been level-headed and made a thoughtful decision, we wouldn't have interned all those people. I think it was mostly panic and we hurried to get rid of all of them so no more bad things would happen at the hands of the Japanese.
DeleteI think that our Government was just taking extreme precautions not to have any chance of a Japanese American defecting. Like, imagine what might have happened if some amount of Japanese Americans in our country took their guns and went out helping their homeland, shooting out soldiers or something. but I do think that the internment camps could have been better-made, to be more like normal homes just, guarded.
DeleteI totally understand where our government is coming from. We are fighting Japan, who is dominating us in the water, we are paranoid for another attack like Pearl Harbor, and the American people are slowly getting more and more frustrated at Japan's successful missions. Even more, Japan is intercepting almost every classified message we send. I can see how desperate the Americans are getting. So they pressure the president into taking action. They just take it the wrong way. They took action by interning innocent Japanese-Americans and treating them badly. Of course, I'm sure there was speculation as to if they were spies or working for the Japanese government. But we should have taken action by recruiting those people to help in the war effort rather than taking them hostage. That cost the US Army men and time to build camps and have guards. Those men surely could have been doing something productive.
ReplyDeleteIt would be like if ISIS bombed us today and then we arrested all Muslims. Hopefully we have learned our lesson and would only focus on the actual dangerous people.
I'm not quite sure what to think about this without knowing more details, but from what I know I think putting the Japanese in camps was overall wrong. Many of these people were completely innocent, and lived in America to get rich, or whatever other reason. It's sad to think every Japanese was locked up, even if they were 1/16th Japanese. But you have to remember we were at war with them, and they bombed us and killed many of our people, so locking up every Japanese was a bit extream but something had to be done.
ReplyDeleteThe law does seem to be outwardly harsh, and similar to what the Germans did to the Jews. But the Germans sent Jews to camps and, well, killed many, for the reason that one man, Hitler, didn't like them, and Hitler put fear into his people so that many Germans wouldn't like Jews either, even though beforehand everyone was working fine together. Even though sending Japanese Americans to internment camps is similar to what Germans did to Jews, it's not the same. I can completely understand why the people and government of the USA made that law. It sorta ruled out at least most of our chances of having spies and Japanese American's defecting to their homeland. Even though most to all of them were loyal to America, I think it was a tough decision for FDR to make, and it was either send Japanese Americans to Internment camps, or risk having defecting Japanese Americans, and hope that they don't cause the USA to lose the war.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Jacob's scenario with ISIS. In fact, reading that made me think...if we take in any amount of Muslim refugees, freely and without care, only thinking that their "poor muslims", what about Terrorists? It's a big chance we'd be taking, letting refugees straight from the Middle East into our country, because how are we going to stop a radical terrorist from dressing up like a war-weary refugee, and passing all his tests and stuff, and enter our country. Behind our backs, basically. This is why the American government had Japanese American's gog to internment camps, because no one knew if they would defect or not, and no one wanted to take that chance, of "new" Japanese soldiers inside the country.
But if I had to make the decision, I would have made the place slightly more homeier, and more like a neighborhood than a war camp.
Update! I think that Japanese Internment during WWII was a really good thing. Why? Well, not all Japanese were sent there. So to lay this out to understand, America took all the Japanese Americans and lined them up in one very long line (this is theoretical), then we asked each and every Japanese American in America to basically prove their loyalty by asking them to salute and say the Pledge of Allegiance to the US Flag. Those who did were set free, those who didn't, were sent to Internment camps. Thus this sort of says that, America was RIGHT to do this. It wasn't cruel at all. Why? Because those who didn't say the pledge, obviously would be rooting for Japan, and America is at war with Japan. So if we had set the disloyal Japanese free, they could have done what Islamic Terrorists are doing today, going out and bombing American cities for their home country, or people they are siding on, which is the Middle East/Islamic people. So I think that that information I just gave should be rather mind-changing on this subject. Many schools and textbooks in at least the public school system, don't say a word on this, they all think that America was discriminating and rude, and well, misjudging. Wrong, America was not any of those, in fact, they were pretty much, really smart. Smart enough to protect themselves from Japanese invasion. (makes me wonder why we aren't doing the same for Mexican immigrants :S (whole different topic which I could go on for hours debating)) I personally really liked how America handled this situation, and I am adding FDR to my favorite presidents list. :)
Deletein the first post: *Go
DeleteOh! also, this reminds me of the prediscrimination that went on during WWI towards the Germans!! except for then we didn't seem to think that Germans were disloyal...??? I wonder if any German Americans were actually disloyal to America but just didn't do anything?!!
DeleteMy thoughts on the Japanese being relocated during this time? I'm not quite sure. I agree with a lot of what Jacob and Kelly said... but like Natalie, I think I'd have to know more about it before making a decision on whether it was a good idea or not. You could easily argue both ways. I think they could have done other things, like putting the Japanese they thought as immediate threats in the camps and leave the families be that had family members in the war, but there would be difficulties with that as well. I'm sure it was a hard decision to make for the government, but we cannot undo what has already been done. Hopefully we can learn from past decisions.
ReplyDeleteMy thoughts on the Japanese-Americans being relocated is that it is one of the terrible things that happened to the immigrants of America. They left Japan for a reason, why would they want to fight for the country they just left, to have a better life. But I can see where the U.S. Government is coming from. I just think they handled it the wrong way. they should have stopped letting Japanese immigrants from coming into the U.S. and just keep an eye on the Japanese-Americans but not to the extent where the Japanese-Americas have to worry about everything they do.
ReplyDeleteMy thoughts on the Japanese-Americans being relocated is, I feel bad but yet I understand that they were worried. I also feel like America would even do this today with Muslims.
ReplyDelete